Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

Your cart

Loading...

Add $40.00 more to unlock FREE SHIPPING.

Estimated total

$0.00 USD

Taxes included. Discounts and shipping calculated at checkout.

Free Shipping on Orders Over $40

Subscribe & Save 10%, Unlock 15% After Your 4th Order

All-Natural. Small-Batch. Long Island Made.

Shop
Bundles
Our Story
Heat Guide
Subscriptions
Recipes

Shop
Bundles
Our Story
Heat Guide
Subscriptions
Recipes

Search

Shop the Sauce

Mild

Mild Medium-Hot Hot Cocktail Mixers

Sort by:

5 products

Filter:

Heat Level (0)

Heat Level

Mild (3 products)

Pack Size (0)

Pack Size

Single Bottle (3 products)

Flavor Profile (0)

Flavor Profile

Approachable Heat (1 product)
Blueberry Forward (1 product)
Bright (1 product)
Fruity (1 product)
Herby (1 product)
Slight warmth on finish (1 product)
Southern (1 product)
Subtle Heat (1 product)
Sweet (1 product)
Sweet stone fruit (1 product)
Tropical (1 product)

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

5 products

Heat Level

Mild (3 products)

Clear

Pack Size

Single Bottle (3 products)

Clear

Flavor Profile

Approachable Heat (1 products)
Blueberry Forward (1 products)
Bright (1 products)
Fruity (1 products)
Herby (1 products)
Slight warmth on finish (1 products)
Southern (1 products)
Subtle Heat (1 products)
Sweet (1 products)
Sweet stone fruit (1 products)
Tropical (1 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

5 products

Build Your Bundle

Build Your

Custom
3
Pack

Save $9

Build Your 3-Pack
Build Your Bundle

Build Your

Custom
5
Pack

Save $22

Build Your 5-Pack
Pineapple Mango Habanero Sauce

Pineapple Mango Habanero Sauce

Regular price $14.00

Regular price Sale price $14.00
Blueberry Carolina Reaper

Blueberry Carolina Reaper

2 total reviews

Regular price $14.00

Regular price Sale price $14.00
Peach Habanero

Peach Habanero

1 total reviews

Regular price $14.00

Regular price Sale price $14.00
Peach Basil Bourbon

Peach Basil Bourbon

Regular price $14.00

Regular price Sale price $14.00
Blueberry Carolina Reaper: "The Dark Bloom"

Blueberry Carolina Reaper: "The Dark Bloom"

Regular price $14.00

Regular price Sale price $14.00

Shop

Hot Sauces
Bundles
Subscriptions

Support

Contact
FAQ
Return Policy

Legal

Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Refund Policy

Social

Instagram
Tiktok
Youtube

Payment methods

© 2026, Long Island Pepper Company Design by DigitalMarketing.inc .

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.